Today, we submitted a response to a Request for Information from the Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP). The OSTP is seeking to develop an “AI Action Plan,” to sustain and accelerate the development of AI in the United States.  As an organization dedicated to advancing the interests of authors who wish to share their works broadly for the public good, we felt it imperative to weigh in on critical copyright and policy issues impacting AI innovation and access to knowledge.

In our response, we reaffirmed our belief that the use of copyrighted works specifically for AI training (distinct from other AI uses) is a quintessential fair use. We noted that Section 1202(b) of the Copyright Act has little utility and serves as an unnecessary stumbling block to the development of AI. We also highlighted the importance of high quality training data and pointed towards the work that is already being done to develop AI training corpora.  

A Few Key Points from Our Submission

Our response to the OSTP highlights several key areas where federal policy can support both authors and a thriving AI research environment:

1. The Role of Fair Use in AI Model Training

We emphasize that fair use has long been a cornerstone of innovation in the U.S.—enabling everything from web search engines to digitization projects. US Copyright law has played a major role in both developing the incredible creative industries homed in the US, as well as driving leading scientific research and commercial innovation. The key to this innovation policy has been a thoughtful balance between providing a degree of control over copyrighted works to copyright holders while allowing for flexibility when it comes to technological innovation and new transformative uses. AI development relies on the ability to analyze large datasets, many of which include copyrighted materials. The uncertainty surrounding the legal status of AI training data due to ongoing litigation threatens to slow innovation. We urge the federal government to explicitly support the application of fair use to AI training and provide much-needed clarity.

2. Addressing the Contractual Override of Fair Use

Many AI developers face contractual barriers that limit their ability to make fair use of content, particularly in text and data mining applications. We recommend legislative measures to prevent contracts from overriding fair use rights, ensuring that AI researchers and developers can continue innovating without undue restrictions.

3. Access to High Quality Datasets

Access to high-quality datasets is a foundational pillar for AI development, enabling models to learn, refine, and iteratively improve. However, the availability of such datasets is often hindered by restrictive licensing agreements, proprietary controls, and inconsistent data standards. To maximize the potential of AI while ensuring ethical and legally sound development, collaborations between academic institutions, libraries, public archives, and technology developers are essential. Government policies should facilitate public-private partnerships that allow for robust and thoughtfully curated datasets, ensuring that AI systems are trained on a rich range of representative materials.

We invite our community of authors, researchers, and policymakers to review our submission. Your engagement is crucial in shaping a responsible and forward-thinking AI policy in the U.S. You can always reach us at info@authorsalliance.org.